Going to the Gym but Not Losing Weight? Here's Why (Christmas Edition)
It's the middle of November. You went back to the gym in September when the kids went back to school, all fired up. You've been turning up. Dark mornings, wet evenings, the lot. And the scales? Barely budged.
Look, I get it. It's a horrible feeling. You're putting the work in and getting very little back, and the easy thing right now is to park it and say you'll go again in January.
Before you do that, have a read of this. Going to the gym but not losing weight is one of the most common things people tell me when they first get in touch. And this time of year makes it a lot harder. That's not you being lazy. It's normal.
Why it's harder to lose weight at this time of year
Nobody really talks about this. In the summer you've a reason to stay on track. A holiday booked, a wedding, a few BBQs in the sun. You're in shorts and a t-shirt most days, so you're thinking about how you look without even trying.
Come November, all of that's gone.
- No goal. There's no holiday to aim for. No date in the diary pulling you along.
- Hoodie season. You're living in hoodies and baggy jumpers. Nobody's seeing your arms or legs till April, so it's easy to let things slide.
- Comfort food is back. The salads and BBQs are gone. Now it's stews, roasts and a takeaway because it's lashing outside and you can't be bothered cooking.
- The walks stop. It's dark at half four, it's cold and it's wet. Your steps drop right off and you don't even notice.
- The Christmas markets. Christmas chips, a hot chocolate with the cream and marshmallows on top, a wee dessert on the way back to the car. It's all right there in front of you.
I'm not saying skip the market. It's part of the fun. But stack all that up and it's no wonder you're not as disciplined as you were in July. Everybody's the same. The difference is knowing it's happening and having a plan for it.
Why you're going to the gym but not losing weight
Here's the bit most people don't want to hear. The gym is brilliant for your health, your strength and how you feel. But on its own, it isn't what gets the weight off. That comes from eating a bit less than your body uses, over time. The NHS says the same: to lose weight, eat and drink fewer calories than your body uses.
Say you train three hours a week. That's 165 hours outside the gym. That's where it's won or lost. Working with clients over the years, it nearly always comes down to one of these.
You're eating it back
You finish a session, you feel you've earned it, and the coffee after the gym turns into a coffee and a traybake. Or dinner gets a bit bigger because you trained today. I've done it myself. Most people think a session burns a lot more than it does, so the deficit they think they're in just isn't there.
You don't really know how much you're eating
That's not a dig. Most people don't. Monday to Thursday might be spot on, then the weekend lands: takeaway on Friday, a few drinks on Saturday, a big Sunday dinner.
The NHS says on average women use around 2,000 calories a day and men around 2,500. It doesn't take a mad weekend to undo the whole week. If that sounds like you, have a read of my piece on banking calories so you can still enjoy your weekend.
You're just turning up and doing a bit of everything
It feels productive. But if every session's different, with no plan and no idea what you lifted last week, you can't tell if you're getting anywhere. I see this all the time with busy parents. They squeeze a session in between work and the school run and just do whatever they feel like on the day. Plenty of effort, no structure.
You're only going by the scales
Your weight goes up and down day to day with water, salt and what you ate last night. Weigh yourself once, see it's up, and it feels like you've failed, even when you're heading the right way.
It also helps to know what normal looks like. The NHS recommends aiming to lose 1 to 2lb (0.5 to 1kg) a week. That's steady, not dramatic. Loads of people expect more than that and pack it in just as it's starting to work.
How to start losing weight again: what I'd do
If you came to me tomorrow and said you're going to the gym but not losing weight, here's what I'd get you doing.
Get your numbers
Find out roughly how many calories you need and what your protein should be. My free calorie calculator gives you both, plus a sample day of eating. The NHS suggests cutting around 600 calories a day as a safe way to lose weight. It doesn't need to be perfect. You just need a starting point. If you want the whole thing laid out, my free Fat Loss Guide walks you through it.
Write down what you eat for two weeks
Not forever. Two weeks. Weekends included, the Friday takeaway included, the bits you pick at while you're making the kids' tea included. Most people learn more in those two weeks than in the last two years.
Follow a plan and log it
Pick a simple plan and stick to it, adding a bit of weight or a rep when you can. You don't need to live in the gym. The NHS guidelines say adults should do strength work for all the major muscles on at least 2 days a week, plus at least 150 minutes of moderate activity. If you're tight for time, here's how I'd get results in 3 sessions a week.
Write it down. My free Training Log needs no account, and here's why logging your training matters.
Get your protein up
Protein helps you keep your muscle while you're losing fat, and it keeps you fuller. A big review of studies on people lifting weights found that going above about 1.6g of protein per kg of body weight a day didn't build any extra muscle. So around that is a good amount to aim for. The calculator will give you your own number.
Plan for the winter stuff
This is the bit most plans miss. Don't wait for the evenings to get your steps in. Get out at lunchtime, or do a lap of the block while the dinner's in. If you're going to the Christmas market, pick the one thing you really want, have it and enjoy it, and skip the rest. And give yourself a goal with a date on it, so there's something pulling you along again, holiday or no holiday.
Look at more than the scales
Weigh yourself a few mornings a week and look at the weekly average. Take your waist measurement and a photo every couple of weeks. Watch your lifts go up in your log. What's worked for clients I've worked with is seeing progress in three or four places, not just one number.
A real story: Conor
Conor came to me in exactly this spot. Training away, putting the effort in, not seeing it pay off. Here's how he put it:
"I had been training for a while before hand but wasn't getting the results I wanted for the effort I put in. I had no structure, little knowledge on nutrition, rest, muscle isolation and accountability."
What changed wasn't him training harder. It was a plan built around his weak spots, and knowing why he was doing it:
"he didn't just tell me what to do he explained why I was doing it the benefit and how it would affect my outcome."
Effort was never Conor's problem. Structure was.
FAQ: going to the gym but not losing weight
Why am I not losing weight even though I go to the gym?
Usually because what you're eating hasn't really come down. The gym helps your health and strength, but weight loss comes from eating a bit less than you use. Eating it back, weekends and guessing portions are the usual culprits.
Is it harder to lose weight in winter?
For most people I work with, yes. No holiday to aim for, baggy clothes, dark evenings that kill your walks, and Christmas food everywhere. Your body hasn't changed. Your routine has. Plan for it and it gets a lot easier.
Can you put on weight when you start going to the gym?
Your weight can bounce around in the first few weeks, with water and sore muscles. That's why I'd look at your weekly average, your waist and your lifts, not one reading.
How long before I see results?
If you're eating a bit less than you use, the NHS recommends aiming for 1 to 2lb a week. Give it a few weeks of tracking properly before you judge it.
Don't wait for January
If you've read this and thought "that's me", don't park it till the new year. Start now, before December gets hard, and go into Christmas already moving.
My 7 Day Kickstart is £7. You get 3 introductory gym sessions with a video for every exercise, your calorie and protein targets, 12 example meal days and a Day 7 review. One good week with a clear plan is all it takes to get going. Get the 7 Day Kickstart here.
Sean Dwyer
Belfast-based personal trainer and online coach with a BSc (Hons) in Sport, Fitness & Coaching and over 12 years of experience coaching clients in person and online.
More about SeanYOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
No Time to Train? How to Get Results in 3 Sessions a Week
Five sessions a week was never realistic. Here is how busy parents and professionals get real results from three, and what to do on each day.
4 November 2026
Read More
Why You Should Log Your Training (And What the Numbers Really Mean)
Training hard but not sure it's working? Here's why a training log matters, how to read it, and what to check when your numbers dip.
29 October 2026
Read More
Is Your Child Falling Behind? The Truth About Youth Strength and Conditioning
Is strength training safe for kids? What is long-term athletic development? A plain guide for parents and coaches, backed by the research.
7 October 2026
Read MoreGET EXPERT COACHING
Want personalised guidance to reach your goals faster? Work with a BSc-qualified coach with over 12 years of experience.
Learn About Coaching